I wrote to the gentlemen listed and he wrote me back immediately. We have been corresponding for the last few weeks. He has someone involved who is helping him help me. She sent him the photos added below.
In the photos below there is a Naomi Dorinda Mason recorded as living in Brooksville, and her father is James Mason. I originally had James Mason as the father, but a cousin insists the father's name is Colonel Charles Mason since that is the name her grandmother (my great aunt with the middle name Verrill (explanation below) called him. The time and location match so I think she is the Dorinda Mason I'm researching.
Below shows "Marriage Intentions." In the first line I noticed the man had the middle name Verrill which is my great aunts middle name. I don't at this point know who this man is, but I thought it was interesting that they shared such an uncommon middle name. On the fifth line down under "Marriage Intentions" Mr. Nickerson Perkins and Miss Dorinda Mason are listed. I believe this is Heman Nicolas Perkins and Naomi Dorinda Mason.